2 The Interview
Where this chapter fits. Step 4 of the research process is to design the method and the forms, and step 6 is to collect the data. This chapter covers the interview guide and the interview.
2.1 Two Ways to Ask the Same Thing
A crisis nursery gives parents a safe place to leave young children for a few hours or days during an emergency. Suppose a nursery wants to learn how parents come to use it. The case is a composite written for this book, and the exchanges below are synthetic.
An evaluator interviews a parent. Here is one way the conversation could go.
Synthetic
Interviewer: Were you satisfied with the nursery?
Parent: Yes.
Interviewer: Did you feel stressed before you came?
Parent: Yeah, pretty stressed.
Interviewer: Would you use it again?
Parent: Probably.
The evaluator asked three questions and received six words. Each question could be answered with yes or no, and each one suggested its own answer. The transcript contains nothing that a three-item survey would not have recorded.
Here is a second version with the same parent.
Synthetic
Interviewer: Tell me about the day you first brought your daughter here.
Parent: It was a Tuesday. I had a court date for the custody thing, and my sitter canceled at seven that morning. I called my mom, she was at work. I called my neighbor, no answer. I was sitting in the car crying, and I remembered a flyer from the clinic.
Interviewer: You remembered a flyer.
Parent: It was on the wall by the scale. I’d seen it maybe ten times and thought, that’s for people in real trouble. And then I was the person in real trouble.
Interviewer: What was it like to make that call?
Parent: Hard. I thought they’d ask a lot of questions. Like, why can’t you handle your own kid. They didn’t. The woman just said, can you be here by nine.
The second version begins with an invitation to tell a story. The interviewer then repeats a phrase the parent used and waits. The parent explains how she learned of the nursery and why she had not used it before. She also describes what she feared and what happened. None of this was in the first version.
An interview is a method, and it takes skill. This chapter covers how to plan one, what to ask, how to follow up, and how to record what was said.
2.2 Three Kinds of Interview
Interviews differ in how much the questions are fixed in advance.
A structured interview uses the same questions, in the same words and order, for every participant. It is a survey that is read aloud. It allows answers to be compared directly and leaves no room to follow an unexpected answer.
An unstructured interview has a topic and no fixed questions. The participant leads, and the interviewer follows. It suits early exploration and long-term fieldwork. The interviews that result can be hard to compare with one another.
A semi-structured interview uses a prepared list of questions and allows the interviewer to change the order and to ask follow-up questions. It is the most common form in applied research, and it is the form this chapter teaches. Every participant is asked about the same topics, and each one can take the conversation where the fixed questions did not reach.
2.3 The Interview Guide
The prepared list of questions is the interview guide. A guide for a one-hour interview usually has six to ten main questions. More than that leaves no time for follow-up.
A guide has four parts.
- The opening. The interviewer explains the purpose, confirms consent, and asks permission to record. Chapter 4 covers consent.
- A warm-up question. The first question is easy and invites a long answer. It shows the participant what kind of conversation this will be.
- The main questions. These follow the research question. They move from general to specific and from less sensitive to more sensitive.
- The close. The interviewer asks whether anything was missed and thanks the participant. “Is there anything I should have asked you and didn’t?” often produces the most useful answer of the hour.
Table 2.1 shows a guide for the nursery study.
| Part | Question | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Warm-up | Tell me a little about your family. | Easy to answer. Establishes who is in the household. |
| Main 1 | Tell me about the day you first used the nursery. | Invites a story. Shows the path to the service. |
| Main 2 | How did you first hear about the nursery? | Identifies sources of information. |
| Main 3 | What did you expect it would be like? | Brings out fears and assumptions. |
| Main 4 | Walk me through what happened when you arrived. | Describes the service as the parent experienced it. |
| Main 5 | What would you have done that day if the nursery had not been there? | Shows the alternatives the parent had. |
| Main 6 | What has been different for you since then, if anything? | Explores effects without assuming any. |
| Close | Is there anything I should have asked you and didn’t? | Catches what the guide missed. |
2.4 Writing Good Questions
Four rules cover most of what separates a useful interview question from a weak one.
Ask open questions. An open question cannot be answered with yes or no. It begins with “how,” “what,” or “tell me about.” A closed question can be answered in a word. Closed questions have a place when the interviewer needs a fact, such as a date. They should be the exception.
Ask for stories and examples. People describe a specific event more accurately than they describe their general habits. “Tell me about the last time that happened” produces more detail than “What usually happens?”
Ask one thing at a time. “How did you hear about us, and what made you decide to come?” is two questions. The participant will answer one and forget the other.
Do not suggest the answer. “That must have been frightening” tells the participant what to feel. “What was that like?” does not.
Table 2.2 shows four weak questions and a revision of each.
| Weak question | Problem | Revision |
|---|---|---|
| Were the staff helpful? | Closed, and suggests the answer | Tell me about the staff you met. |
| Don’t you think the hours are too short? | Leading | How do the hours work for you? |
| Why didn’t you ask your family for help? | Sounds like blame | Who else did you think about asking that day? |
| How did you find us and what did you think? | Two questions | How did you first hear about the nursery? |
A question that begins with “why” needs care. “Why did you wait so long?” can sound like an accusation, and the participant may defend the choice. “What was going on for you during that time?” asks for the same information with no judgment attached.
2.5 Work With the Data: Interview Guide Checker
Table 2.2 showed four weak questions and a revision of each. The tool checks a whole guide for the same problems. It marks closed questions, leading questions, double questions, and questions that begin with “why.”
Open Interview Guide Checker in its own window
- Press “Check the guide” for the sample guide of seven questions. The tool flags four of them.
- Rewrite each flagged question in the box. Use the revisions in Table 2.2 as models. Check the guide again.
- Replace the sample with a guide of five to seven questions for a topic you know. Put one question on each line.
- Revise until most questions are open and none is flagged for leading.
The tool uses fixed rules. It cannot tell whether your questions are in a sensible order or whether they cover the research question. Read the guide aloud to another person before the first interview.
2.6 Probes
A probe is a follow-up that asks the participant to say more. Probes are not written in advance. The interviewer chooses them while listening. Most of the detail in a good interview comes from probes.
Five probes cover most situations.
- Silence. Wait three or four seconds after the participant stops. People often continue with something more considered. New interviewers find this the hardest probe to use.
- The echo. Repeat the participant’s last few words. “You remembered a flyer.” It shows that you are listening and invites more.
- The request. “Tell me more about that.”
- The example. “Can you give me an example?”
- The clarification. “When you say ‘real trouble,’ what do you mean?”
The last probe matters most for analysis. Participants use words that carry meaning for them. The interviewer should ask what those words mean and should not assume. “Real trouble” in the exchange above shows how the parent had sorted herself into a group that did not need the service.
2.7 Listening
An interviewer has three tasks at once. The first is to hear what the participant is saying. The second is to decide what to ask next. The third is to keep track of which topics on the guide have been covered. Beginners often attend to the guide and miss what was said.
Three habits help. Bring the guide on one page and learn it well enough that you need only glance at it. Take brief notes on phrases to return to. Let the participant finish, and do not fill a pause with the next question.
The interviewer should talk far less than the participant. In a transcript of a good interview, the interviewer’s turns are short, and the participant’s turns are long.
The interviewer also has to manage the relationship. Rapport is the trust that lets a participant speak freely. It comes from interest and respect. It does not come from agreeing with everything the participant says. An interviewer who reacts with approval to some answers teaches the participant which answers are wanted.
2.8 Recording and Transcribing
Most interviews are recorded on audio, with the participant’s permission. A recording lets the interviewer listen fully and preserves the exact words.
A transcript is a written record of the recording. A verbatim transcript records every word, including repeated words and unfinished sentences. For most applied research, a verbatim transcript that leaves out “um” and “uh” is detailed enough.
A transcript needs a few conventions, applied the same way throughout. Mark who is speaking. Mark pauses and laughter in brackets where they affect the meaning. Mark words that could not be heard as [inaudible] and do not guess. Replace names of people and places with labels such as [sister] or [employer]. Chapter 4 explains why.
One hour of audio takes four to six hours to transcribe by hand. Automatic transcription is now common and much faster. It makes errors, and the errors are more frequent with accents, crosstalk, and poor audio. Someone has to check every automatic transcript against the recording.
Right after each interview, write a memo. A memo is a note from the researcher to herself. Record what stood out, what surprised you, how the participant seemed, and what to ask differently next time. These notes are data. They also show a later reader how the researcher’s thinking developed.
2.9 Focus Groups
A focus group brings six to ten people together for a guided discussion of 60 to 90 minutes. A moderator asks the questions and manages the conversation.
A focus group is not a way to interview eight people at once. Its value is the interaction. Participants respond to one another, disagree, and build on what others say. A group can show which views are shared and which are disputed.
A focus group suits topics that people discuss with others in ordinary life, such as a neighborhood, a product, or a public service. It is a poor choice for sensitive personal topics. A parent may not describe a custody dispute in front of seven strangers. A group can also be dominated by one or two voices, and some participants will agree with the room and keep their own view private.
A moderator needs a shorter guide than an interviewer does. Four to six main questions are enough. The moderator also has two extra tasks. One is to draw out the quiet participants. The other is to keep any one person from taking over.
2.10 Before the First Interview
Test the guide before using it. Conduct one or two pilot interviews with people similar to the participants. A pilot shows which questions are unclear, which produce short answers, and how long the interview runs. Revise the guide and test it again if the changes are large.
The guide may also change during the study. If the third participant raises a topic that no question covered, the interviewer can add a question for the remaining interviews. This is a normal part of qualitative research. Record each change and the date it was made.
An interview in person gives the most information, because the interviewer can see the participant’s reactions. A phone interview costs less and can feel more private for some topics. A video interview falls between the two. Choose the mode that is easiest for the participant. A parent with no car and two young children may prefer a phone call during a nap.
An interview about a hard time can bring that time back. A parent who describes the day she called the nursery may begin to cry. The interviewer’s first duty is to the person and not to the data. Stop the questions. Offer a pause, and offer to end the interview. Do not press for more because the account is useful. Before the study begins, prepare a short list of local services that the interviewer can give to any participant who wants one. The consent process should tell participants that they may skip any question and stop at any time.
Automatic transcription saves many hours. It also changes words without notice. It can turn “I couldn’t pay” into “I could pay,” and it often drops short words such as “not.” It may assign a sentence to the wrong speaker. An analysis built on an unchecked transcript can quote a participant as saying the opposite of what was said. Listen to the recording while you read the transcript and correct it. There is also a privacy question. Before you upload a recording to any service, find out where the audio is stored and who can use it. The consent form should say which service will be used.
2.11 Putting It All Together
A semi-structured interview uses a prepared guide and allows follow-up questions. A guide has an opening, a warm-up, six to ten main questions, and a close. Good questions are open, ask for stories, ask one thing at a time, and do not suggest an answer.
Probes produce most of the detail. The main ones are silence, the echo, the request for more, the request for an example, and the clarification of a term. The interviewer listens more than she talks and writes a memo after each interview.
Interviews are recorded and transcribed, and an automatic transcript has to be checked against the recording. A focus group shows how people respond to one another and suits topics that are not private.
2.12 Looking Ahead
The guide is ready. The next decision is whom to interview. A survey draws a random sample. A qualitative study chooses its participants on purpose, and the reasons for each choice matter. Chapter 3 covers how to choose and how to know when enough people have been interviewed.
2.13 Further Reading and References
- Rubin, H. J., and Rubin, I. S. (2012). Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data (3rd ed.). Sage. A practical guide to main questions, probes, and follow-up questions.
- Spradley, J. P. (1979). The Ethnographic Interview. Holt, Rinehart and Winston. The source of the “grand tour” question that asks a participant to describe a typical event.
- Weiss, R. S. (1994). Learning From Strangers: The Art and Method of Qualitative Interview Studies. Free Press.
- Krueger, R. A., and Casey, M. A. (2015). Focus Groups: A Practical Guide for Applied Research (5th ed.). Sage.
- Brinkmann, S., and Kvale, S. (2015). InterViews: Learning the Craft of Qualitative Research Interviewing (3rd ed.). Sage.
2.14 Key Terms
- Closed question. A question that can be answered with yes, no, or a single word.
- Focus group. A guided discussion among six to ten participants.
- Interview guide. The prepared list of questions for an interview.
- Memo. A note from the researcher to herself about what was observed or thought.
- Moderator. The person who leads a focus group.
- Open question. A question that cannot be answered with yes or no.
- Pilot interview. A trial interview used to test the guide.
- Probe. A follow-up that asks the participant to say more.
- Rapport. The trust that lets a participant speak freely.
- Semi-structured interview. An interview with prepared questions and freedom to change the order and follow up.
- Structured interview. An interview with the same questions in the same words and order for everyone.
- Transcript. A written record of a recorded interview.
- Unstructured interview. An interview with a topic and no fixed questions.
- Verbatim transcript. A transcript that records every word.
2.15 Exercises
Check Your Understanding
- Name the three kinds of interview and state how they differ.
- List the five probes in this chapter. Which one did the interviewer use in the second exchange with the parent?
- Why is a focus group a poor choice for a study of custody disputes?
- Why does an automatic transcript have to be checked against the recording?
Apply It
- Rewrite each question as an open question that does not suggest an answer. (a) “Was the application process confusing?” (b) “Did you feel judged by the staff?” (c) “Why didn’t you call sooner?”
- Write an interview guide of six main questions for this study. “How do first-year college students decide where to live?” Include a warm-up question and a closing question.
- Read transcript H03 in the corpus. Find one place where the interviewer used a probe and one place where a probe would have helped. Write the probe you would have used.
Think Deeper
- An interviewer nods and says “right, exactly” whenever a participant criticizes the landlord. What effect could this have on the interview? What should the interviewer do in its place?
- During the fifth interview of a study, a participant raises a topic that none of the first four mentioned. Should the interviewer add a question about it for the remaining interviews? What is gained, and what problem does it create?
- Conduct a 15-minute practice interview with a friend about their last move. Record it with permission. Listen to it and count how many of your questions were closed. Report what you would change.